Articles | Protis Global

Retained Search ROI for Consumer Brand Hires

Written by Lars Miller | Aug 25, 2026, 1:00:00 PM

Retained search ROI compares the cost of a search with the value of filling a role effectively: vacancy time, internal effort, assessment quality, and the cost of restarting after an unsuccessful hire. Use your company’s assumptions and the actual agreement to make that comparison.

By Lars Miller. Last updated: November 10, 2026.

What retained search actually costs

The engagement agreement sets the fee, compensation basis, and payment terms. Protis Global uses milestone-based installments: the second installment is triggered when a slate, typically two to three people, is approved by the client to interview; the final installment is paid upon placement. Compare the full scope and terms when evaluating proposals.

Two contract mechanics change the math and get missed. First, the replacement period: Protis Global will replace a placed person without an additional search fee if they leave during the period covered by the agreement. This is typically 90 to 120 days and can be longer under some contracts. Second, when switching firms during a search, review how both agreements treat candidates already introduced or interviewed. Agree on any exclusions in writing. Before you sign anything, read our guide on what to know about retained search before signing a contract.

The cost of the alternatives

Running it yourself

An internal team may be well equipped to run the search. Include the time required to define the role, research and approach candidates, screen applicants, coordinate interviews, and manage offers. Assess whether the team can reach the relevant market alongside its other work.

Contingent search

Contingent arrangements generally link the fee to a successful placement. Exclusivity, assessment, research, and service commitments vary by agreement. Compare the proposed work and accountability rather than assuming the fee model alone determines quality.

Building an internal search function

An internal executive recruiting function may make sense when hiring demand is sustained. Compare its full cost and available capacity with the number, complexity, and timing of planned searches. There is no single company-size threshold that settles that decision.

The costs to include alongside the fee

Cost of vacancy

An open role can delay decisions, add work to other leaders, and interrupt execution. Identify which outcomes are actually constrained by the vacancy. Use the contribution or cost attributable to that gap, rather than treating an entire revenue plan as lost value.

Protis Global’s searches average 46 days from kickoff to signed acceptance, compared with the 60-day industry norm. Use the same milestones when comparing timelines, and track the person’s start date separately. A search average is a planning reference rather than a promised completion date. See our speed-to-hire playbook.

Cost of a mishire

Estimate the direct costs of an unsuccessful hire using your own assumptions: compensation during the unsuccessful period, onboarding, any applicable separation costs, and the work of restarting the search. Record disruption to the team or customer relationships separately where it can be reasonably supported. Avoid a universal percentage that may not describe your role or business.

For a first-in-function leader, consider how the person will build capability and make decisions across the team. Separate that potential value from a financial return already achieved. Our guide to first C-suite hires at emerging brands explores how to define that mandate.

What the fee buys, mechanically

The fee pays for a defined search process. Assess that process and its results using consistent measures:

  • A market map instead of an applicant pool. Research maps the category before outreach starts, so the search draws from everyone who could do the job rather than everyone who happened to apply. More on the mechanics in how retained search improves CPG executive hiring.
  • Search timing. Track kickoff to signed acceptance against agreed milestones, then record time to start separately.
  • Internal time. Record the hours your team spends on screening, interviewing, and decisions, alongside the quality of the candidates assessed.
  • Offer acceptance and retention. Track offers extended, offers accepted, starts, and retention over a defined period. Keep the cohort and dates consistent when comparing results.
  • Replacement coverage. Protis Global replaces a placed person without an additional search fee if they leave during the replacement period covered by the client’s agreement. That period is typically 90 to 120 days and may be longer under some contracts. The signed agreement sets the applicable period and terms.

A simple ROI worksheet

Line How to estimate it
Retained fee Use the quoted fee and its compensation basis from the agreement
Cost of vacancy Estimated monthly contribution or avoidable cost attributable to the vacancy × months open. Compare equivalent timeline milestones
Mishire risk Company-specific estimates for unsuccessful tenure, onboarding, separation where applicable, and restarting the search
Internal time Actual hours spent researching, screening, interviewing, and coordinating × a consistent hourly cost assumption
Multiplier effect Identify expected capability gains and attributable outcomes; avoid double-counting benefits already included above

Calculate potential ROI as estimated net benefit divided by search cost, using a stated time horizon. Show conservative and higher-benefit scenarios, document assumptions, and compare actual results after the hire starts. Do not treat every improvement after a hire as caused by the search.

When retained search is the wrong answer

Choose the approach that fits the work. An internal team or contingent arrangement may suit a well-defined role with an accessible candidate pool. Wait if budget or decision authority is unresolved. When the work is temporary or the permanent mandate is still emerging, consider interim or fractional support through ace Talent Curators. Role title alone should not determine the search model.

For a deeper vertical version of this math, see our piece on measuring executive recruiting ROI in wine and spirits.

Frequently asked questions

What does retained executive search cost?

The engagement agreement sets the fee, compensation basis, and payment terms. Protis Global uses milestone-based installments: the second installment is triggered when a slate, typically two to three people, is approved by the client to interview; the final installment is paid upon placement. Compare the full scope and terms when evaluating proposals.

Is retained search worth it for a consumer brand?

It can be, when the agreed research, assessment, and search support address a meaningful hiring need. Compare the actual fee with realistic vacancy, internal-time, and restart-cost assumptions. The result depends on the role, available alternatives, and execution.

How do you measure executive search ROI?

Compare estimated attributable benefits and avoided costs with the full search cost over a stated period. Track vacancy time, internal hours, offers, starts, and retention. Keep assumptions separate from observed results and avoid double-counting benefits.

What happens if the hire doesn't work out?

Protis Global replaces a placed person without an additional search fee if they leave during the replacement period covered by the client’s agreement. That period is typically 90 to 120 days and may be longer under some contracts. The signed agreement sets the applicable period and terms.

Can we avoid paying twice if we switch search firms mid-search?

Review both firms’ agreements and identify candidates already introduced or interviewed before switching. Any exclusions or fee responsibilities should be agreed in writing. Do not assume a new engagement cancels obligations under the previous agreement.

What is the cheapest way to fill an executive seat?

There is no universal cheapest option. Compare the total cost and suitability of internal recruiting, contingent search, retained search, and interim or fractional support. A temporary solution may address an immediate need, while a permanent ownership requirement calls for a different comparison.

Protis Global has run retained executive search for consumer goods companies since 1995, across food and snacks, beverage, beer, wine and spirits, pet, cannabis, and health and beauty. If you're weighing a fee against an empty seat, talk to our team.

Related Reading